Three years after Nancy's selfless act to save her family, Andy, Silas, Shane and Doug live their new lives in Copenhagen. When Nancy is released early from prison and put on parole to a New York halfway house, she finds out that she doesn't need witness protection anymore.
Nancy tries to establish a life in New York City, and is surprised by the unannounced arrival of Andy and Shane. Meanwhile, Silas begins doing modeling work, and Doug tries to track down an old friend.
While Nancy is having trouble fitting in at the halfway house, her sister Jill gives her some unexpected news. Meanwhile, Andy and Shane find a place to live in New York City, while Silas books his first modeling job, and Doug is offered a job.
Nancy attempts to land a job at Doug's new office, while Shane sets up their new house without the help of an overwhelmed Andy.
Silas and Nancy's lawyer assist her in getting to California as her custody battle with Jill (Jennifer Jason Leigh) heats up. Meanwhile, Andy's relationship takes an intriguing turn; Shane decides to give it the old college try and enrolls in classes; and Doug is left to fend for himself at his job on Wall Street.
Nancy's attempt to rekindle her business with Heylia doesn't go well. In the meantime, Andy introduces a new idea of venture to Shane and Doug.
Nancy uses Doug's softball game with the company team to sell weed on the sidelines. In the meantime, Andy and Silas open their bike and weed shop.
The reappearance of Zoya who used to share a cell with Nancy means trouble for Nancy. Meanwhile, Andy and Silas have disagreements about their venture and Shane's intership at the police turns out to be very informative for him.
While Silas has another run-in with his rivals from Pouncy House Party Rentals, Andy and Nancy trie to stop Zoya from taking control of the bike shop and Doug faces the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Nancy, Andy and Silas plot revenge against Emma (Michelle Trachtenberg) after she gives them the business in a business deal. Meanwhile, Doug suffers a financial setback that makes it even more important to keep his hedge fund up and running; and Shane's involvement with the law proves to be more involving than he expected.